11 April 2007 Blog Home : April 2007 : Permalink
Stem cells are immature cells which can become different types of adult tissue.
and the Times similarly says:Stem cells are immature, unprogrammed cells that have the ability to grow into different kinds of tissue and can be sourced from people of all ages.
The Times article then goes on to make what Tim W perceives as a gratuitous swipe at President Bush by bringing up the embryonic stem cell issue. I agree with Tim that if you are going to mention Bush's ban on federal stem cell funding it helps if you get the details right. i.e. mention that the ban is merely on the federal funding of research. However Tim does get a bit confused here:It might also be worth noting a further fact. The phrase "most versatile" is as yet unproven. There are as yet no treatments at all that stem from (sorry) embryonic stem cells, but there are as above, some very interesting ones from adult lines. We might yet find out that adult line sare indeed more versatile, especially when we consider the subject of rejection.
No one has yet identified any adult stem cell that can create all cell types. This is precisely what both Auntie and the Wapping Liar get wrong or at least make it so that a casuak reader will misunderstand. Adult stem cells can only produce a handful of cell types, in almost all cases just one cell type, so if you harvest pancreatic stem cells (say) then you won't be able to grow bone marrow or heart muscle from them. On the other hand embryonic stem cells can actually make any sort of cell so that in theory an embryonic stem cell could be used to make any part of the body from brain to toenail. This fact (the abaility of embryonic stem cells to make anything but adult ones to only make limited sorts of cells) has been demonstrated all over the place in scientitic literature and was one of the reasons why the ability to clone entire organisms by inserting their DNA into a denuclearized embryo was such a surprise. In fact IIRC part of the problem with adult stem cells is that we haven't yet identified stem cells for every cell type. Another problem is that some stem cells are hard to get at. E.g. the brain stem cells appear to live in the middle of the brain so getting access to them without harming the rest of the brain is a non-trivial exercise.